Carbon Like Center
 |
No items matching your keywords were found.
The Carbon Offset Controversy
Every day people do dozens of things that put more carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. This gas is the main perpetrator of climate change, yet activities like driving, heating your house, air travel, and electricity consumption, are hard to stop. Individuals that want to reduce their carbon footprint, the amount of carbon dioxide generated in a year, have the option of buying carbon offsets, often called renewable
energy credits, or RECs
Carbon offsets are projects that decrease the amount of greenhouse gases (GHG) like carbon dioxide in the air to counterbalance the amount that an individual has emitted. These projects can include, but aren't limited to planting trees (carbon sequestration), erecting wind turbines or solar panels, reducing methane (a greenhouse gas more potent, but less common than carbon dioxide), or updating manufacturing processes to use less fossil fuel.
To offset the average US household energy consumption of 10,656 kWh per year, 3Phases, a large wind company in the Midwest, charges $213.00. 3Phases will use this money to produce, in theory, 10,656 kWh extra in wind energy by building that many more turbines. This new renewable energy will be added to the grid in the place of conventional energy, like coal. The pricing of carbon offsets for alternative energy firms is based on the price difference between fossil fuel energy production and the alternative energy production per kilowatt hour.
In all cases, the money from the offset purchase must instigate additional reductions by the company. Otherwise, the price of the credit will not accurately reflect the amount of GHG reductions it caused. Community Energy Inc., a Pennsylvania-based organization operating in New Jersey, is one of several companies doing the same thing.
As offset purchases have become more popular, journalists and researchers have raised the alarm and cautioned consumers about offsets that do little more than make you feel good. The major concern centers on additionality. Carbon mitigation is only additional if it occurs at a level above the baseline level, also called 'business as usual'. Ideally, the offset you buy should initiate extra reductions that could not have happened without the money you spent. Additionality is hard to measure: large firms are already working to reduce their GHG-producing activities, and offset purchases, especially small ones, may not actually instigate enough new activity to fully offset the promised amount of kilowatt hours.
A recent New York Times article publicized these problems. To many environmentalists, the carbon-neutral campaign is a sign of the times, easy on the sacrifice and big on the consumerism, Andrew Revkin reported in his piece Carbon Neutral Is Hip, but Is It Green? Revkin quotes Denis Hayes, a leading sustainability activist and expert; the worst of the carbon-offset programs resemble the Catholic Church's sale of indulgences back before the Reformation, he says. Instead of reducing their carbon footprints, people take private jets and stretch limos, and then think they can buy an indulgence to forgive their sins.
In the past year, researchers discovered that Al Gore, director of the climate change documentary An Inconvenient Truth, has a carbon footprint twenty times the national average; his mansion consumes almost 221,000kWh (kilowatt hours) a year. Gore buys offsets to legitimize this enormous fossil fuel consumption, but many question if his offset purchase actually exempts him from his climate change sin.
Citizens in China use an average of 6 carbon tons per year, and in India, the average is less than half that. In the United States, however, the average person generates around 25 carbon tons per year. Many environmentalists feel we should be reducing our carbon consumption by taking big steps to change our personal and organizational habits and use different technologies and/ or fuels, instead of taking the easier path of changing nothing, and spending money to transfer the reduction responsibility to others. Different offset providers have different pricing schemes, which further complicates the issue of additionality.
Most people familiar with the offset market, including offset providers, encourage individuals first to take steps to reduce the amount of energy they use before making an offset purchase. Conserving electrical energy by turning off lights and computers at night, buying fuel-efficient appliances and vehicles, and being an informed consumer about the food you buy can all make significant reductions in your carbon footprint.After taking these steps, only carbon offsets can mitigate the remaining GHG emissions, allowing individuals to go completely carbon neutral.
In summary, trees don't reduce carbon, they sequester it for as long as they live. Energy conservation is probably the best way to lower your carbon footprint.
Carbon offsets essentially fund additional carbon reduction that would not happen otherwise.
Individuals and institutions have 3 ways to lighten their carbon footprint:
1) Reduce your own energy consumption
2) Replace dirty energy with clean
3) Facilitate and fund energy conservation by others, particularly those who cannot afford to do it themselves
About the Author
James Nash is a climate scientist with Greatest Planet (www.greatestplanet.org). Greatest Planet is a non-profit environmental organization specialising in carbon offset investments.
James Nash is solely responsible for the contents of this article.
|
|
Stanton Cfb-1 Carbon Fiber Brush $19.95 Stanton CFB-1 Carbon Fiber Brush |
|
|
Used Mxr Carbon Copy Delay $99.99 In Store Used USED MXR CARBON COPY DELAY |
|
|
Used Onerr Carbon X Overdrive $19.99 In Store Used USED ONERR CARBON X OVERDRIVE |
|
|
Meinl Fibercraft Designer Series Conga Carbon 11 $549.99 Meinl Fibercraft Designer Series Conga Carbon 11" |
|
|
Audix Mb5050 50 Carbon Fiber Boom System $499 Audix MB5050 50" Carbon Fiber Boom System |
|
|
Pdp Z5 5-Piece Drum Set Carbon Black $329.99 PDP Z5 5-Piece Drum Set Carbon Black |
|
|
Pdp Z5 5-Piece Shell Pack Carbon Black $249.99 PDP Z5 5-Piece Shell Pack Carbon Black |
|
|
86901 Carbon Fiber Center Diff Upper Plate $5.81 Carbon Fiber Center Upper Plate |
|
|
85901 Carbon Fiber Center Diff Upper Plate $11.92 Carbon Fiber Center Upper Plate |
|
|
Used Garrison G20 Carbon Fiber Frame $299.99 In Store Used USED GARRISON G20 CARBON FIBER FRAME |
|
|
Used Mxr Carbon Copy Analog Delay $109.99 In Store Used USED MXR CARBON COPY ANALOG DELAY |
|
|
Used Rocket Shell 4Pc Carbon Fiber 032612 $1499.99 In Store Used USED ROCKET SHELL 4PC CARBON FIBER 032612 |
|
|
Tribology of Diamond-like Carbon Films $134 Since their initial discovery, Diamond Like Carbon films have enjoyed an overwhelming interest. This book highlights some of the most important structural, chemical, mechanical and tribological characteristics of DLC films. It talks about the fundamental tribological issues that impact the durability of these coatings. |
|
|
Used Blue Spark (Like New) $149.99 In Store Used USED BLUE SPARK (LIKE NEW) |
|
|
Used Simmons Sdmk2 Like New $59.99 In Store Used USED SIMMONS SDMK2 LIKE NEW |
|
|
Used Audiobox Usb Like New $74.99 In Store Used USED AUDIOBOX USB LIKE NEW |
|
|
Rainsong Studio Series S-Ws1000n2 Acoustic-Electric Guitar Carbon $1499 Rainsong Studio Series S-WS1000N2 Acoustic-Electric Guitar Carbon |
|
|
Karl Willhelm Carbon Fiber Violin Bow 4/4 Size Black $119.95 Karl Willhelm Carbon Fiber Violin Bow 4/4 Size Black |
|
|
Karl Willhelm Carbon Fiber Viola Bow 4/4 Size Black $129.95 Karl Willhelm Carbon Fiber Viola Bow 4/4 Size Black |
|
|
Karl Willhelm Carbon Fiber Cello Bow 4/4 Size Black $139.95 Karl Willhelm Carbon Fiber Cello Bow 4/4 Size Black |
|
|
Pdp Z5 Completedrum Set W/ Hardware & Cymbals Carbon Black $399.99 PDP Z5 CompleteDrum Set w/ Hardware & Cymbals Carbon Black |
|
|
Used Pearl Limited Edition Carbon/Mahogany 14 Snare $259.99 In Store Used USED PEARL LIMITED EDITION CARBON/MAHOGANY 14" SNARE |
|
|
Fender Guitar Upgrade Resistor Metal/Carbon Film 4.7K 1/4W Nte $2.99 Fender Guitar Upgrade Resistor Metal/Carbon Film 4.7K 1/4W NTE |
|
|
Marshall Mg Series Mg100hcfx 100W Guitar Amp Head Carbon Fiber $305.99 Marshall MG Series MG100HCFX 100W Guitar Amp Head Carbon Fiber |
|
|
Pdp Z5 5-Piece Drum Set With Cymbals Carbon Black $399.99 PDP Z5 5-Piece Drum Set with Cymbals Carbon Black |
|
|
Pork Pie Big Boy Camouflage Drum Throne Black/Charcoal Carbon $199.99 Pork Pie Big Boy Camouflage Drum Throne Black/Charcoal Carbon |
|
|
Mxr M169 Carbon Copy Analog Delay Guitar Effects Pedal $149.99 MXR M169 Carbon Copy Analog Delay Guitar Effects Pedal |
|
|
Rainsong Studio Series S-Dr1000n2 Acoustic-Electric Guitar Carbon $1217.13 Rainsong Studio Series S-DR1000N2 Acoustic-Electric Guitar Carbon |
|
|
Rainsong Concert Series Co-Ws1000n2 Graphite Acoustic-Electric Guitar Carbon $2087.13 Rainsong Concert Series CO-WS1000N2 Graphite Acoustic-Electric Guitar Carbon |
|
|
Pearl Carbonply Maple Marching Tom #301 Carbon Fiber Matte 6X8 $244.99 Pearl CarbonPly Maple Marching Tom #301 Carbon Fiber Matte 6x8 |
|
|
Rainsong Studio Series S-Om1000n2 Acoustic-Electric Guitar Carbon $1304.13 Rainsong Studio Series S-OM1000N2 Acoustic-Electric Guitar Carbon |
|
|
Used Legacy Ae Guitar Carbon Fiber Wc 042412 $799.99 In Store Used USED LEGACY AE GUITAR CARBON FIBER WC 042412 |
|
|
Dunlop Max Grip Jazz Iii Carbon Fiber Guitar Picks - 24-Pack $9.99 Dunlop Max Grip Jazz III Carbon Fiber Guitar Picks - 24-Pack |
|
|
Pearl Primero Pro Oak Bongo Set Carbon Vapor $137.4 Pearl Primero Pro Oak Bongo Set Carbon Vapor |
|
|
Used Adamas Ovation W597 Carbon Fiber Top Ae Gtr Wc $899.99 In Store Used USED ADAMAS OVATION W597 CARBON FIBER TOP AE GTR WC |